My Gym Is Reopening. Is It Safe To Work Out There?

Jul 5, 2020
Originally published on July 16, 2020 9:09 am

Exercise is good for physical and mental health, but with coronavirus cases surging across the country, exercising indoors with other people could increase your chance of infection. So, as gyms reopen across the country, here are some things to consider before heading for your workout.

Assess your own risk

It starts with you, says Dr. Saadia Griffith-Howard, an infectious disease specialist with Kaiser Permanente.

"You have to make your own assessment of how risky it is based on knowing your medical situation and whether you are someone who's at high risk for an infection," Griffith-Howard says.

People 65 years and older are at higher risk for getting a severe case of COVID-19, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. So are people with certain underlying health conditions, like diabetes, heart or lung disease, or those who are immunosuppressed.

So if you fall in a high risk category, Griffith-Howard says it may not be worth the risk.

"If it was someone in my family [who was high risk] I would suggest that they not go to a gym," she says.

Consider alternatives for working out

If you want to exercise indoors, it's safer to do it at home, says Doug Reed, an immunologist and aerobiologist at the University of Pittsburgh.

"That's what I'm doing now," he says. "When the weather's nice, I'm jogging outside, but when it's not, I'm doing some weights and stretches and exercise indoors."

Exercise outdoors is a great low-risk alternative, agrees Dr. Nikita Desai, a pulmonologist with the Cleveland Clinic. When you are outside it's easier to control how close you get to other people.

"I would be less worried about the jogger who is running past you for a split second and more worried about the person who's working out next to you without a mask for half an hour," she says.

And the risk of transmission is lower outside than inside, says Joshua Santarpia, a microbiologist who studies biological aerosols at the University of Nebraska Medical Center.

"Outdoors you have sunlight which has been shown to quickly inactivate the virus," he says. And outside airflow and humidity help dilute it.

If you do go: Assess your gym's safety measures

There are things gyms can do to help mitigate the risk of infection, so Griffith-Howard suggests making a checklist before you go.

"Are they taking your temperature?" she asks. "Are you seeing them regularly clean equipment? And are staff and other clients in the gym wearing a mask?"

Official guidance for how gyms should proceed varies state by state. Gyms are not open yet in some states, or open with restrictions in others — find your state's restrictions here. Most guidelines suggest limiting capacity to keep the gym from getting crowded, routine disinfection of all equipment including machines and weights before and after use, posting signs to reinforce hygiene and other policies, and all recommend physical distancing.

In fact, that should be the number one thing on your checklist: Is there at least six feet of physical distance between everyone who is working out? Even more would be better. Another tip: Go during off hours when they'll be fewer people.

Some clubs have constructed exercise pods to ensure physical distancing. Others have gone touchless and are encouraging members to use a mobile app to check-in, says Sami Smith, Communications and Public Relations Assistant for the International Health, Racquet & Sportsclub Association, which has developed guidelines for clubs to use as a reference when planning their reopening.

Stay far apart. Really

This bears repeating — stay at least six feet away from other people while you are exercising. And, if people are breathing heavily, "it would be preferable to double that to 12 feet," says Dr. Lou Ann Bruno-Murtha, division chief of infectious diseases at Cambridge Health Alliance in Cambridge, Mass.

That's because we don't know exactly how far virus particles travel when people are breathing heavily," says Doug Reed, an immunologist and aerobiologist at the University of Pittsburgh.

"When you are exercising and exerting yourself, you're going to be breathing out and breathing in more than you normally would, he says.

"And so the potential for being infected or spreading the infection would be that much higher," says Reed.

And if you're thinking about taking a group exercise class, think again, says Griffith-Howard, because it can be very difficult to keep six feet apart when moving around quickly.

"You may be breathing harder, people may be coughing, it may be hard to keep on masks," she says. "I would have some concerns about that."

A small study from South Korea looked at coronavirus spread at 12 different sports facilities. It found that infection spread rapidly among high intensity fitness dance classes with up to 22 students. Whereas yoga and pilates classes, with just seven or eight participants and little moving around, saw no spread.

So if you really want to take a group exercise class make sure it's small and that you can maintain a distance of six to 12 feet away from others.

Pay attention to air flow

Steer clear of small gyms and those with little ventilation, says Desai of the Cleveland Clinic.

"Your best bet is going to be a gym that is larger, able to have windows open or have multiple floors or levels to allow for physical distancing," she says.

That's because more space and more air flow dilute the concentration of the virus in the air and likely reduce the risk of transmission.

"If you're strenuously exercising then you're tending to draw in and exhale more air," says aerobiologist Reed.

This is especially important because there's increasing evidence to suggest "that people who are not symptomatic are, in fact, transmitting the infection," says Reed.

In fact levels of the virus found in the nose or throat of asymptomatic or pre-symptomatic individuals "can be considerable and are equivalent" to the amount of virus found in individuals with symptoms of coronavirus, he says.

So people who feel well enough to exercise may not realize they are infected, and may be on the weight machine next to you.

Should I wear a mask?

Our experts say it's best wear a mask as much as possible in the gym, including at the front desk, in the locker room and the bathroom — and even while doing light exercise. But of course, when you're working out hard and breathing heavily it can be difficult to keep a mask on.

"Physical exercise doesn't lend itself well to the idea of wearing a mask," says Reed, because it can make it harder to breathe.

And while many gyms recommend masks, most don't require them.

"If you're doing aerobic type exercises on an aerobic type machine, you probably are not wearing a mask," says Bruno-Murtha of the Cambridge Health Alliance in Cambridge.

And even if people don a mask when they enter the gym, Bruno-Murtha still highly recommends maintaining at least a minimum 6-foot physical distance, "because I suspect at some points people may inadvertently remove their mask," she says which can be risky for others.

"Physical exercise is important for your physical and mental health but you still have to be smart," says Bruno-Murtha. "Wearing a mask is part of being smart, along with physical distancing, disinfecting equipment and vigilant hand washing."

Location, location, location

And, finally consider your geographic location. Exercising indoors in hot spots where cases are surging is more risky than in areas with low infection rates says Bruno-Murtha. So check out this color coded tracker to look up the COVID-19 risk in your county, and nearby counties.

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

All across this country, gyms and fitness centers are reopening, and you may be eager to get back to your normal exercise routine. Should you? NPR's Patti Neighmond reports.

PATTI NEIGHMOND, BYLINE: In some states where coronavirus cases are surging, gyms are closed, but in most other states, they're open. So deciding whether to go or not starts with assessing your risk, says Dr. Saadia Griffith-Howard, an infectious disease specialist with Kaiser Permanente.

SAADIA GRIFFITH-HOWARD: You have to make your own assessment of how risky it is based on knowing your medical situation. Are you someone who's at high risk for an infection?

NEIGHMOND: Do you have diabetes, heart or lung disease? Are you obese or over 65?

GRIFFITH-HOWARD: We know that that puts you at a bigger risk for having severe disease. And at this time with all of the unknowns about the virus, certainly, if it was someone in my family, I would suggest that they not go to a gym.

NEIGHMOND: If you're under 65 and healthy and really want to go to the gym, then Griffith-Howard suggests a checklist to assure the facility is taking adequate precautions.

GRIFFITH-HOWARD: Are they taking your temperature or not? Is the equipment spread out so that you're at least 6 feet away from other people who may be exercising with you? Are you seeing them clean the equipment? Are the staff wearing a mask? Are other clients in the gym wearing a mask?

NEIGHMOND: Most state guidelines suggest routine disinfection of all equipment before and after any use. And the absolute must - at least 6 feet of physical distance between everyone who's working out. Respiratory specialist Dr. Nikita Desai with the Cleveland Clinic says steer clear of small gyms and those with little ventilation.

NIKITA DESAI: Your best bet is going to be a gym that's larger, that is able to have windows open or have multiple floors or levels to allow for that physical distancing.

NEIGHMOND: More space and more airflow can help dilute the virus - that's a good thing, of course - since high-intensity exercise means a lot more heavy breathing. Immunologist Doug Reed studies airborne transmission of respiratory disease at the University of Pittsburgh.

DOUG REED: When you're exercising, exerting yourself, you're going to be breathing out more and breathing in more than you normally would be, and so the potential for being infected or spreading the infection would be that much higher.

NEIGHMOND: Particularly since people may be infected but not yet have symptoms. Others may be asymptomatic.

REED: I think with asymptomatic or pre-symptomatic individuals, there is accumulating data to suggest that they do produce a considerable amount of virus without their really being aware of it, and levels of virus that are found in the nose or in the throat are equivalent to people who are symptomatic.

NEIGHMOND: Some gyms recommend masks, but Reed says they can be cumbersome to wear while exercising.

REED: Especially if you're strenuously exercising, then you're tending to draw in more and exhale more air.

NEIGHMOND: If people take their masks off, it can be risky for others. Now, if you're thinking you might return to group exercise classes, think again, says Dr. Griffith-Howard. It can be difficult to keep 6 feet apart when moving around quickly.

GRIFFITH-HOWARD: As you're continuing the exercise, you may be breathing harder. People may be coughing. It may be hard to keep on masks. So, to me, I would have some concern about that.

NEIGHMOND: A small Korean study found infections spread rapidly among high-intensity dance classes. Yoga and Pilates classes with just seven or eight participants and little moving around saw no spread. The consensus among these scientists - if you're going to exercise indoors, your home is the safest, or if possible, exercise outdoors. Respiratory specialist Desai.

DESAI: I would be less worried about the jogger who is running past you for a split second and more worried about the person who is working out next to you without a mask for half an hour.

NEIGHMOND: Outside conditions lower the risk of transmission. Microbiologist Joshua Santarpia studies airborne virus at the University of Nebraska Medical Center.

JOSHUA SANTARPIA: Outdoors you have sunlight, which has been shown to quickly inactivate the virus. And furthermore, you've got both the temperature and the air, sort of the outdoor conditions, and the airflow that will help dilute the virus away from you.

NEIGHMOND: Finally, consider your geographic location. Exercising indoors in hot spots where cases are surging is more risky than in areas with low infection rates. Patti Neighmond, NPR News.

(SOUNDBITE OF LCD SOUNDSYSTEM'S "YEAH") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.